Over 100 lawyers have expressed concerns to the Ministry of Justice regarding proposed changes to jury trials. This proposal, which aims to significantly limit jury trials to only the most serious cases, is anticipated to be officially announced next week. The letter from the lawyers, including 23 King’s Counsel members, emphasized that the recommendations from Sir Brian Leveson’s report are unlikely to address the court backlog.
The plan would introduce judge-alone trials for most offenses, a move the signatories label an “irremediable error” that could undermine a longstanding legal right. Jodie Blackstock, a barrister, indicated alarm over the lack of responsiveness from the Ministry of Justice, stating that these new intentions extend beyond Leveson’s recommendations which lacked evidence.
The Criminal Bar Association has also voiced its discontent. Chair Riel Karmy-Jones KC highlighted concerns that reducing jury trials might weaken the relationship between the state and the populace, potentially eroding trust in the justice system. A leaked letter has outlined that juries would only assess public interest offenses that carry potential prison sentences of over five years, such as murder or rape, while judges would handle serious offenses with sentences up to five years.
The reforms would also expand magistrates’ powers, allowing them to preside over cases with sentences up to two years, further limiting jury trial rights. Courts Minister Sarah Sackman noted the backlog of around 80,000 cases, asserting the situation is detrimental to both victims and defendants. She mentioned that many individuals awaiting trial have faced significant life disruptions, indicating that prolonged waiting periods can hinder justice.
The Ministry of Justice has responded, stating no final decision has been made and acknowledging the ongoing “crisis” in the court system. They emphasized the need for action to alleviate the backlog affecting victims and the judiciary.
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/law/2025/nov/30/plan-to-reduce-jury-trials-an-irremediable-error-lawyers-say-in-moj-letter