Sir Jim Ratcliffe has recently commented that the standards of Manchester United’s academy have declined in recent years. This comes amid significant changes within the academy, particularly following the departure of Nick Cox, its long-term leader, who left to join Everton. His successor, Steve Torpey, was brought in from Brentford and is regarded as a close collaborator of Jason Wilcox, the club’s director of football.
Recent discussions at the academy have highlighted concerns that its needs have been somewhat sidelined and underfunded while efforts were focused on improving the first team. Despite a £50 million investment in training facilities, the academy operates from temporary structures located in the players’ car park, with future plans for modernization that align with the first team’s infrastructure. Ratcliffe has clarified that his comments on slipping standards specifically relate to facilities.
Within the academy, there has been emotional feedback regarding the perceived neglect of its needs. Notably, Wayne Rooney has also expressed concern about the current culture of the club, observing staff job losses and the potential effects on his children, who are part of the academy system.
Recruitment issues are complicating the academy’s situation, as financial disparities with other Premier League clubs limit its competitiveness for top staff. The departure of several key staff members has raised further questions about stability, leading to worries among parents regarding the academy’s ability to retain experienced personnel.
The importance of fostering homegrown talent remains critical, as indicated by comments from Ruben Amorim about the potential of youth players and their role in the team’s future. While the academy has produced some notable graduates, overall productivity has been a concern, with only a few players making notable contributions to the first team this season.
As the new leadership strives to implement changes, the challenge of restoring the academy’s renowned reputation and output continues to be a pressing issue for Manchester United.
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/football/2025/nov/29/manchester-uniteds-academy-reeling-from-staff-churn-and-ratcliffes-brickbats