A YouTube video titled She says Both Pilots INOPERATIVE. Real ATC Audio is gaining attention, claiming to feature real air traffic control (ATC) audio from Tap Air Portugal flight TAP484H, which was en route from Lisbon, Portugal, to Nice, France. The audio reportedly involves a misunderstanding between the pilot and French ATC, where the pilot stated the toilets were inoperative, but the controller misheard it as pilots being inoperative.
The date of the incident is unspecified, and several media sources are referencing this video without additional context. The initial audio appears to have surfaced on Instagram on July 2, detailing a request from the flight for a direct routing due to malfunctioning toilets, which raised passenger concerns for an early landing. After some confusion, the issue was clarified, allowing the flight to continue normally.
Concerns have been raised regarding the legitimacy of the video. Critics point out the absence of corroborating details, including specific dates and sources for the ATC communications, which may violate French privacy laws. Additionally, there are questions about how internal ATC phone conversations became part of the recording.
- Why it matters: Miscommunications in aviation can have serious implications for passenger safety and air traffic management. This incident highlights the necessity for clear communication protocols in high-pressure situations.
- The video illustrates the challenges in ATC communication, underlining the importance of precise language in aviation.
- The latest: As of now, the video has not been independently verified, and discussions continue regarding its authenticity and the implications of sharing such recordings without consent.
Source: https://fearoflanding.com/demystifying/pilots-or-toilets/
Source: https://fearoflanding.com/demystifying/pilots-or-toilets/